Search Atlas Otto SEO Review: Why I Cancelled AHREFs after Testing It (Late 2025)

Last Updated November 8, 2025 in Blogging, SEO

Author: Nate McCallister
Search Atlas review

TLDR Quick Answer: "Is Search Atlas Worth It"

Yes, if you're a serious blogger who is making income from your site. Although it's not perfect, it's the best SEO tool I've ever used. It was so impressive that I am cancelling AHREFs after 10 years and moving to Search Atlas exclusively. I don't anticipate the current price to be as low as it is now forever, so I'd lock into the current rates while they're low and still growing their early base of founding members. Also, they offer a free 7 day trial 

I spent the week diving deep into Search Atlas. My blogs are my livelihood and I needed to make a decision on if it was an upgrade over the tools I've grown comfortable with over the years: AHREFs, Surfer SEO and SEMRush being the big three. 

After testing out every feature relevant to my business, I'm ready to share my full and honest Search Atlas review. 

We're going to review it in several key areas. 

1. Initial Set Up

Search Atlas is clearly powerful, but will the average website owner be able to actually navigate the tool and benefit from it? Is the interface intuitive and logical or do you need to work hard to figure out how to make use of things? Does it take a lot of work and time to get started? How long does it take to actually see real world changes?

2. User Friendliness and UI

Search Atlas is clearly powerful, but will the average website owner be able to actually navigate the tool and benefit from it? Is the interface intuitive and logical or do you need to work hard to figure out how to make use of things? Does it take a lot of work and time to get started? How long does it take to actually see real world changes?

3. Functionality

What can Search Atlas do and what can it not do? Do the feature actually lead to real world results and make the process faster and easier?  We will analyze the following core functions.

  • SEO Admin Automations
  • Keyword ResearchAuthority Optimization
  • Auditing
  • Link Building and Research
  • AI Placement
  • PPC Management
  • Local SEO
  • Content Writer

4. Value (Pricing)

How does Search Atlas compare to the big name tools like AHREFs and SEMRush in terms of cost to features and value? Does it do enough to justify being near the same price range? Are there hidden upgrades (like in SEMRush) that make the initial tool price misleading?

5. Accuracy

Is the data provided accurate? Having a lot of data is meaningless and counter productive if it isn't accurate. I compare to the best of my abilities by cross checking data with Google Search console and other 3rd party tools to see. 

Search Atlas Initial Set Up: A-

I pretty easily integrated my WordPress website using Cloudflare. Even though there were multiple steps required that I would never have known to do on my own, the step by step instructions they provided made it easy. The only hiccup was that there was a delay in the confirmation of successful installation that fixed itself after a few minutes.

Just like everyone else, I had to pay for Search Atlas. I didn't receive any complimentary access for this review and I didn't have any coupon codes or promotions. 

I picked the 7-day trial of the Growth (mid-tier) plan. That is the plan that is best compares to what I currently pay for now in AHREFs and SEMRush. 

Here's what my initial set up looked like (and most of yours will as well). 

  1. Project + Integrations: Started a project for EntreResource.com and connected Google Search ConsoleGoogle Analytics, and Google Ads.
  2. Pixel/Plugin: Installed the WordPress plugin and began the OTTO installation.
  3. Cloudflare step: Required an API token and zone setup. The guided flow was clear but fiddly—I had to double-back a few times to get it right.
  4. Status & Syncing: Some processing delays and “is it really connected?” moments—especially with GSC and the OTTO pixel. Support will likely be needed if you hit the same snags.


Search Atlas User Friendliness and UI: B+

I was conflicted here. Considering how robust the program is, it is extremely user friendly. The only reason it didn't get an A+ is because I'm certain newer users will struggle to navigate it simply because of the depth of functions. Some features are overkill for DIY bloggers and it can be a little overwhelming jumping between what is useful and what should be skipped.

Basic Appearance

The Search Atlas dashboard is a work of art. As a tech nerd, I will so far as to use the word gorgeous to describe it. 

It's also fast and free of glitches (so far). It isn't very mobile friendly, but serious SEO work isn't something you'd want to do on your phone anyway.

It is however a bit overwhelming. Pages and subpages galore. It will probably take me a full year before I've navigated every possible node available. 

Data Views

The basic data views I'm using are things like organic keywords, paid keywords, AI overview sightings, competitors, backlinks, and intent breakdowns.

They all come with filters and column 

Accuracy: Like every SEO suite, some differences vs. Ahrefs/GSC. I saw keywords that didn’t line up perfectly and traffic/volume estimates that didn’t always match. That’s normal—GSC is the ultimate tie-breaker.

Difficulty & volume gaps: I compared terms (e.g., “Search Atlas,” “Search Atlas review”) across Search Atlas vs. Ahrefs. Difficulty ratings and volumes didn’t always agree.

My take: I’ve long felt Ahrefs can understate volume on some queries; here, Search Atlas occasionally felt a bit higher than Ahrefs—yet in at least one test with my own impressions/clicks, Search Atlas’s global volume estimate was closer to reality.

Search Atlas Functionality: A+

The amount of things you can do in Search Atlas is unbelievable. Few businesses will leverage a majority of the possible features, but unlike tools like SEMRush that charge you for each, they are all included in the base price. 

Let's dive into each of the core features of Search Atlas, starting with the one that got me to join in the first place: seo automations. 

SEO Admin Automations 

Search Atlas advertises as a time saver that can automate the tedious tasks we all have to live with as SEOs and bloggers. 

It wasn't false advertising. It does work as advertised. 

Search Atlas content audit

Now, as someone who takes his websites very seriously, the idea of fully automating anything isn't something I'm comfortable with. Which is why Search Atlas is so great. It allows you to choose whether you want to fully automate or manually. 

Search Atlas audit and automation

I am in love with the AI generation feature on the OTTO suggested fix. It does use a credit each time, but it's worth it and you have plentyl

Otto SEO Suggestions

The suggestions seem to follow SEO best practices at a high level. If the average blogger were to blindly accept and implement them all, the results wouldn't be as perfect as if an expert did them manually, but there would be noticeable improvements in much less time. AI bulk editing will have a little collateral damage, but I think it's worth it. Just keep an eye on things and make sure that you don't accidentally damage a money page.  

My one complaint with some of the automated updates is that they aren't always front facing. Meaning, they are in the code and not on the actual page. I find this tactic to be a bit spammy and I don't like it at scale. It's reminiscent of stuffing 100 keywords in all white text at the bottom of blog posts in the early 2000s.  That is just for some things though, not important articles.

Pros

  • One click optimization is available for many tasks.
  • Suggestions are typically very good.
  • Can solve years of issues in minutes.
  • Can isolate fixes and customize them.

Cons

  • Some suggestions are bad.
  • Some updates are coded, not shown on pages.
  • Cloudflare integration can cause weird glitches.

Al Placement Data

Seeing how your website appears in LLMs like ChatGPT and Perplexity is a big deal in the world of content marketing. Unfortunately, 3rd party program like AHREFs and SEMRush have set the pricing for this data into astronomical levels. Even on high cost plans, seeing AI placement data is limited and often costs extra. 

AHREFs LLM AI Tracking Cost

Search Atlas shows all of your AI placements without additional costs or wildly restrictive limitations. 

Search Atlas LLM

Keyword Research

The keyword research functionality inside of Search Atlas is exceptional. It is very similar to the big name programs.

Search Atlas Keyword Research

You can track keywords, see estimated CPC, find related keywords and see keyword difficulty which is based on many factors and seems to be accurate to me. 

It provides search intent and allows you to easily filter by region. The keyword magic tool will give you additional keyword ideas that you can rabbit trail down to find topics you might not have thought about. 

OTTO Seo magic keyword

You can also compare your rankings to your competitors with the keyword gap too.

keyword gap tool

PPC Management

This is not a feature I plan on using much, but it seems fully capable. It currently only supports Google ads but Meta appear to be in the works.

Search atlas ppc management

Topical Authority Optimization

Google has made it clear that topical authority is a big factor in their algorithm. Search Atlas helps you see Topical Maps and what they call "Topical Dominance" which is based on how you compare to competitors in your niche. 

Local SEO

Search Atlas clearly put a high priority into local SEO. I don't do local SEO so this feature was hard for me to give this a fair review. 

From what I saw, it appears to be easy to follow and implement changes to things like your location, business intent etc.  It connects with a few clicks to your "Google Business Profile" and gives you flexibility to optimize from there. 

Google my business

Link Building and Research

The Search Atlas link building and research functionality is on a completely different level than any alternatives. 

It's like Justreachout, Hunter.io and AHREFs had a baby and then put that baby on steroids. 

Whereas AHREFs gives you the ability to see who you might want to build links with, Search Atlas lets you actually contact them from inside the software. 

Search atlas outreach

They even integrated a link exchange service I had never heard of but am using now called "Link Laboratory."

Link Laboratory

Content Writer

I’m honestly impressed with Search Atlas’s Content Editor (they call it Content Genius / Otto). Right off the bat it feels like someone finally built an editor that understands the real content workflow — keyword → brief → draft → optimize — and stitches most of that together in one place.

Search Atlas Content Editor

Here’s why I like it

  • Speed and workflow: The AI-powered briefs and bulk writing are huge time-savers. I can generate topic clusters, outlines, and first-draft content in minutes instead of hours. For teams cranking out lots of posts, that’s a multiplier.
  • Practical optimization: The editor doesn’t just spit out copy — it gives on-page guidance (recommended internal/external links, suggested number of tables, structural hints), so the draft already leans toward being publishable.
  • Templates & rewriting: Built-in templates and a solid rewriter make it easy to humanize or rework raw AI text. That’s handy when you want to move away from obvious “GPT voice.”
  • Team features & exports: I like the status workflows (in progress / needs review), HTML export, and the ability to hand off briefs cleanly. That makes it work well for small agencies or content teams.
  • Extras I didn’t expect: Meta generation, hero image creation, infographics — and support for tables/callouts — set it apart from some tools I use. Some competitors don’t do tables or integrated image assets like this. The image generation was actually better than the ones in other tools like Surfer (which I actually prefer overall for the content editor features).

Search Atlas Accuracy: B+

Although their database of links and keywords might not be as robust as AHREFs and SEMRush just yet, Search Atlas has seemed very accurate. 

  • Link data is 95% identical to other tools. 
  • Keyword data matches Google Search Console data.
  • Content grading and auditing seems based on sound best practices.

Overall, the accuracy of Search Atlas is top notch. 

Search Atlas Value: A+

Pound of pound, Search Atlas is the most value packed SEO tool I've ever used. The only problem someone might have with the price is that it's unlikely you'll use all of the features, so it might feel like you're overpaying. You aren't. If you use a tool like AHREFs, you'd need to break into the $1,000+/month range to meet Search Atlas's functionality. If you tried to create your own bundle of features with SEMRush, you'd almost certainly end up paying more than you'd pay with even the highest tier of Atlas. 

There is no discount or annual option yet, but the 7 day free trial is more than enough to make a decision.

Final Word

You owe it to yourself to at least give Search Atlas a free trial. It might change everything for your websites. 

overall 4.7/5 Surfer SEO Review TL:DRSurfer SEO remains one of the best on-page

Few of the tools I pay for each month have had the

Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the products and services mentioned on this website pay affiliate commissions to the creators at no cost to you. Thank you for your support!