Disclosure: this post contains affiliate links. If you sign up through them I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
I run newsletters on both platforms, so this is a comparison from inside two live accounts, not from two pricing pages. My Kit list has about 29,000 subscribers. My beehiiv list, Leaves and Soul, has about 7,500.
The short answer
beehiiv gives you more ways to make money from the list itself. Kit has paid me more per send.
- Pick beehiiv if the newsletter is the business. You get an ad marketplace, paid recommendations, a sponsorship storefront and 0% fees on paid subscriptions, and you can start with a small list.
- Pick Kit if email sells something else: your products, your affiliate offers, your course. Its automations are deeper, and once you pass 10,000 subscribers its sponsorships can pay well. Mine have.
Want to try them while you read? Start with beehiiv (code NATE20 takes 20% off) or start with Kit.
The rest of this post shows the screens and the real numbers behind that answer.
Kit vs. beehiiv at a glance
| Feature | beehiiv | Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Up to 2,500 subscribers | Up to 10,000 subscribers |
| Paid plan at 10,000 subscribers | Lite: $139/mo, or $119/mo billed yearly | Creator: $139/mo |
| Built-in sponsor ads | Ad Network, on paid plans | Newsletter Sponsorships, historically for 10,000+ subscribers |
| How ads pay | Per click, or per 1,000 opens | Per click |
| Get paid to recommend other newsletters | Yes, $0.80 to $2.40 per subscriber in my marketplace | Yes, Kit reportedly keeps about 23.5% |
| Sell your own sponsorships | Storefront on the Pro plan | No storefront; handle it yourself |
| Programmatic ads | In beta, request access | Listed inside sponsorship reports |
| Paid subscriptions | 0% platform fee | Yes, with a transaction fee |
| Digital products and tips | Yes, 0% platform fee | Yes, about 3.5% + 30¢ per sale |
| Referral program | Yes | Pro plan |
| Automations | Good trigger list | Deeper: visual builder plus sequences |
| AI connector (MCP) | Yes | Yes |
Prices checked November 2026. Sources: beehiiv’s October 2026 pricing announcement, PPC Land’s coverage of the change, and EmailVendorSelection’s Kit pricing breakdown.
What each one costs, and when the money features unlock
Kit is cheaper to start. beehiiv turns on monetization sooner.
Kit’s free plan covers up to 10,000 subscribers. beehiiv’s free plan stops at 2,500. If you only want to send email and grow, Kit costs you nothing for much longer.
The catch is what the free plans leave out. On beehiiv, ad monetization and paid subscriptions start on the Lite plan. On Kit, unlimited automations and paid recommendations start on Creator, which runs $39 a month at 1,000 subscribers and $139 at 10,000.
beehiiv changed its plans on October 1, 2026. Scale became Lite and Max became Pro, and prices went up. At 10,000 subscribers Lite is now $139 a month, or $119 a month billed yearly. Pro is $239, or $199 billed yearly.
So at 10,000 subscribers the two cost about the same. The question is what that fee buys you, and that is where they split.
How beehiiv makes you money
beehiiv has five monetization tools, and three of them work on a small list.
1. The Ad Network
This is beehiiv’s marketplace of pre-negotiated sponsor ads. You open Offers, pick one, and drop it into a post. beehiiv has said you can apply with 1,000 subscribers.

My account shows 8 available offers right now. Most pay per click, from $1.05 to $2.62. One pays $3.75 per 1,000 opens. You can hold up to 5 offers at a time and have 5 days to publish each one.

Before you add an ad, you choose the angle and the format. Ads with the sponsor’s logo are marked as earning 2x, and there are text-only versions if you want the ad to read like your own writing.

The Reports tab shows what each ad earned and when it pays out.

2. Paid recommendations
Other newsletters pay you for every subscriber you send them. In my marketplace the offers run from $0.80 to $2.40 per subscriber. You can also recommend for free.

It works in the other direction too. You can pay to be recommended, which is how I’ve added 124 subscribers to Leaves and Soul.

3. Direct sponsorships
If you would rather sell your own ads, beehiiv gives you a storefront where a brand can book a slot. My sample storefront lists a single sponsorship at $125 and a monthly package at $499. This one needs the Pro plan.

4. Programmatic ads
You add an ad slot and beehiiv fills it automatically at send time. It is still in beta in my account, behind a request-access button. beehiiv’s CEO has said their cut usually sits around 15 to 20%.
5. Paid subscriptions, products and referrals
beehiiv takes 0% of paid subscription revenue and 0% of digital product sales. There is also a referral program that rewards readers for bringing in subscribers.
How Kit makes you money
Kit has fewer monetization tools, but its sponsorships have earned me far more per send.
1. Newsletter Sponsorships
Kit brings sponsor offers to your dashboard. You review an offer, schedule it, and Kit handles the brand side. Kit’s sponsor program has historically asked for 10,000 or more subscribers and a weekly send, so this is not a day-one feature.
My current offers pay $2.10 and $2.29 per click from Morning Brew and Superhuman. A second tier of campaigns pays $1.14 per click.

The Reports tab adds it up. I have run 20 campaigns for about $3,800 in total, at an average of $2.07 per click.

You can open any campaign to see exactly which email it ran in. One Superhuman placement went to 29,451 people, got 227 clicks, and paid $519.83.

2. Recommendations
Kit’s Creator Network lets creators recommend each other at signup. It is free to use, and on paid plans you can also charge for recommendations. Kit reportedly keeps about 23.5% of that.
For me it has been a growth tool more than an income tool. 55 creators recommend my list, and those recommendations have converted at 10.44%.

3. Products, paid newsletters and tips
Kit has its own checkout for digital products, paid newsletters and a tip jar. The fee is about 3.5% plus 30 cents per sale. If you already sell through another checkout, you probably won’t switch for this.
What Kit doesn’t have
There is no storefront for selling your own sponsorships, and no open marketplace where you browse and claim ads on a small list. If your list is under 10,000, Kit’s built-in ad income is close to zero.
My real numbers on both
Per send, Kit’s sponsor ads have paid me roughly three to four times what beehiiv’s have.
| Metric | beehiiv (Leaves and Soul) | Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Subscribers | 7,491 | 29,015 |
| Typical send size | About 3,800 | About 30,000 |
| Open rate | 36.04% | 32.80% |
| Sponsor ads run | 14 | 20 |
| Total ad earnings | $91.99 | About $3,800 |
| Average per ad | About $6.57 | About $190 |
| Earnings per 1,000 recipients, per ad | About $1.73 | About $6.30 |
| Best single ad | $15.75 | $519.83 |
Source: my own beehiiv and Kit dashboards, November 2026.
This is not a clean test, and I won’t pretend it is. The lists are in different niches. One is about houseplants and the other is about online business and AI tools.
The per-click rates are actually close: $1.05 to $2.62 on beehiiv and $1.14 to $2.29 on Kit. The gap is in clicks. A Kit campaign averages about 92 clicks for me. A beehiiv ad averages two or three. Adjusted for send size, my Kit readers click sponsor ads four to five times as often.
That is mostly an audience difference, not a platform difference. What the platforms do control is access. beehiiv started sending me offers on a list of a few thousand. Kit’s sponsorships only make sense once you are past 10,000.
The features that feed the money
Kit is the better selling machine. beehiiv is the better publishing tool.
Automations. beehiiv’s automations cover the triggers a newsletter needs: signups, forms, polls, surveys, referrals, upgrades and purchases. Kit goes further. You get a visual builder, separate email sequences, and tag-based rules, which is what you want when different subscribers should see different offers.


Landing pages and forms. Kit is built around them. I have dozens of lead-magnet pages in one account, each feeding its own sequence. beehiiv has landing pages, signup forms and one-click subscribe links too, but running many lead magnets with separate follow-ups is easier in Kit.

Templates and the website. beehiiv wins here. It has a template library, a hosted site for your archive, and posts that live on the web as well as in the inbox.
Integrations. Kit’s app store is large, with Shopify, WordPress, Zapier, Canva and many more. beehiiv has fewer native integrations.

AI connectors. Both now have an MCP connector, so you can point Claude or ChatGPT at your account and ask about growth, engagement or what to send next.

So which one should you pick?
Choose by how the list makes money, not by the feature count.
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Under 2,500 subscribers, no product yet | beehiiv Free, or Kit Free | Both cost nothing. beehiiv’s upgrade path leads to ads; Kit’s leads to automations. |
| 1,000 to 10,000 subscribers and you want ad income now | beehiiv Lite | The Ad Network and paid recommendations work at this size. Kit’s sponsorships mostly don’t. |
| You sell courses, products or affiliate offers | Kit Creator | Sequences, tags and landing pages earn more than ads will. |
| 10,000+ engaged subscribers in a business or tech niche | Kit | Sponsor offers get meaningful, and you keep the stronger automations. |
| The newsletter is the product: ads, paid tiers, sponsors | beehiiv Pro | Storefront, 0% subscription fee and the ad marketplace in one place. |
Plan names and features as of November 2026.
If I were starting a content newsletter from zero today, I would start on beehiiv. If I were building a list to sell my own offers, I would start on Kit. I run both because I do both.
Try beehiiv and use code NATE20 for 20% off · Try Kit
Questions people ask before they choose
Can I make money on the free plan of either one? Barely. beehiiv’s free plan lets you sell digital products, but ads and paid subscriptions need Lite. Kit’s free plan lets you sell products and collect tips, but paid recommendations need Creator.
How many subscribers do I need before ads pay anything? On beehiiv, about 1,000 to get offers. Expect a few dollars per ad at that size. On Kit, plan on 10,000 or more before sponsorships show up.
Do the platforms take a cut of my ad money? The rate you see on a sponsor offer is what you are paid on both. beehiiv takes 0% of paid subscriptions and product sales. Kit charges a transaction fee on sales and reportedly keeps about 23.5% of paid recommendations.
Can I run my own sponsors alongside the built-in ads? Yes on both. beehiiv says its Ad Network is non-exclusive, and it gives Pro users a storefront for direct deals. On Kit you arrange direct sponsors yourself.
Is it hard to switch later? No. Both import subscribers by CSV, and Kit offers free migration on paid plans. Rebuilding automations is the real work, so switch before you have many of them.
Can I use both? Yes, and I do. Just don’t put the same subscribers on both, or you pay twice for the same person.
Ready to pick one?
Both have a free plan, so you can test either one before you pay anything.
Use code NATE20 for 20% off a paid plan.
